19 West Cayuga Walk

High End Property with all the Amenities of Home.

3 Bedroom, 1 Bath, House, sleeps 9
No Pets, Non-Smoking

This type of house is not usually found on the rental market. When we renovated this house we cut no corners and spared no expense. The entire floor plan was redone to balance the sleeping space and the living space. All new wood floors adorn the space; all new furniture and beds await you. The kitchen is fully equipped for your stay. There is a shower on the outside deck.

When you agree to rent this house, your mind is free of questions regarding the cleanliness and condition of the house. This house is exceptional when compared to owner occupied houses on the island and is in a class by itself when considered as a rental.


Bedroom One: Has a full on bottom and twin on top bunk.
Bedroom Two: Has a full on bottom and twin on top bunk.
Bedroom Three: Has a full on bottom and twin on top bunk.

Rental Season Periods and Pricing

Our rental season begins in early May and goes through October. We rent generally two types of periods, first are Midweeks: Mondays at 3pm through Fridays at 10am Weekends: Friday at 3pm through Monday at 10am.

May and June
Midweeks and Weekends (Please Call)

July and August
Midweeks are $3250
Weekends are $3750

September and October
Midweeks and Weekends (Please Call)

Memorial Day Weekend is $4750
July 4th Weekend $4750
Labor Day Weekend is $4750
Miss Fire Island Weekend (Please Call)
This property is registered with the County Of Suffolk Office of the Comptroller and all prices include 3% Suffolk County Hotel/Motel Tax.

[siteorigin_widget class="Events_CalendarWidget"][/siteorigin_widget]

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need keys to the house?

The keys are inside a keypad that is attached to the front door of the house. You punch in the code that you are given before you show up, and the key comes out for your use.

From the Ferry, How do I get to 19 West Cayuga Walk?

Leave the wagon area and make a left at the police station on Bay View Avenue and go three blocks to Cayuga Walk, and make a right. Go South towards the Fire Island Hotel. We are house #19, which is the ninth house on your right, located at the corner of Cayuga Walk and Midway. Make a right at Midway and walk around the house, to the entrance on Midway. The entrance is is marked with a sign over the doorway "19 IKEA West"

How far of a walk is the house from the ferry?

Our houses are about a five minute walk from the ferry terminal.

For More Questions visit our Frequently Asked Questions Page

How Things Work

The process is to check if your dates are available on the calendar to the right, then contact Stephen at (516) 721-7818 or via email to arrange the period. After we speak and arrange a period, we will fax a contract out for your review and you will return it along with payment prior to your stay. Late reservations may require either Fed Ex or similar delivery to avoid occupancy prior to funds clearing or arrival. Prior to your stay you will be given the codes to the key box located on the doorframe of the house. These codes will unlock the house, bikes, beach chairs and wagon.

And Much More! View all Amenities here.